An Analysis of the Differences in Aerodynamic Drag among Bullet-shaped, Canted Nose at Subsonic Velocities
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61173/kp1arc81Keywords:
Drag force, Nose shape, Pressure drag forceAbstract
Drag force is very important for high-speed rail’ s energy efficiency and operating speed. This study compares bullet-nosed and canted-nosed train designs through meta-analysis of existing experimental data and verifies the validity of the possible explanations through existing simulations. The result shows that the bullet-nose train can reduce 29.2% of drag force in 41.66 m/s and 35.6% in 79.1667 m/s, which primarily because of a better pressure management and the reduction of flow separation. Although it is superior in aerodynamics, the durability of the canted-nose design reflects necessary compromises on crosswise stability and space requirements. These findings provide a quantitative guidance for the superiority of bullet-nose in reducing drag force compares to canted-nose. Moreover, this paper analyzes the cause and the physical principle behind the phenomenon by dividing the composition of drag force. Also, this study reveals the balancing between aerodynamic performance with other critical design considerations in current and future train development.
References
mance hierarchy where bullet-nose designs demonstrate Policy, 2007, 41(1): 3-23. approximately 29.2% in 41.66 m/s and 35.6% in 79.1667 [2] Dhumal A, Ambhore N, Tamkhade P, et al. Numerical m/s lower drag coefficients ( Cd ) compared to canted-nose Optimization for Aerodynamic Performance of Nose Cone of
FSAE Vehicle through CFD. CFD Lett, 2024, 16: 161-171. configurations across operational speed ranges. Compared [3] Shaiful Anuar, M. S., Kariem Shater, S., & Sapit, A. with the canted noses with a lower length-to-height ra- Aerodynamic Study of High-Speed Train’s Drag Coefficient by tio, the noses with a streamlined body and the ones with Computational Fluid Dynamics. Journal of Complex Flow, 2024, a large length-to-height ratio and a shape similar to a 6(1): 16–22. streamlined body, like the bullet noses, can make the wake [4] Tian Li, Dai Zhiyuan, Yu Mengge, et al. Numerical adhere to the rear of the vehicle, prolongs the separation Investigation on the Aerodynamic Resistances of Double-unit time of the wake at the rear of the vehicle. In addition, Trains with Different Gap Lengths. Engineering Applications of this nose can also reduce the generation of a large number
Computational Fluid Mechanics, 2021, 15(1): 549-560. of vortices at the rear to dissipate energy, create a smaller [5] Dunlop, J. Slipstream Control for High-Speed Trains. pressure difference with the front of the vehicle body, and Doctoral dissertation: Monash University, 2021. thereby achieve the purpose of reducing pressure differ- [6] Sun Zhenxu, Yao Shuangbao, Wei Lianyi, et al. Numerical ence resistance. This further elaborates the authenticity Investigation on the Influence of the Streamlined Structures of and reason for the low drag of the bullet nose. the High-speed Train’s Nose on Aerodynamic Performances. The research mainly contributes to synthesizing simula-
Applied Sciences, 2021, 11(2): 784. tion data from the source to provide quantitative evidence [7] Silvestri L. CFD modeling in Industry 4.0: New Perspectives for a better nose type in reducing the drag force in a con-
for Smart Factories. Procedia computer science, 2021, 180: 381- siderable speed. Also, this research investigates the aero- 387. dynamic trade-off, providing potential causes and reasons [8] Wu Z, Zhou D, Li S, et al. Numerical Analysis of the Effect of the drag induction. Furthermore, the flow charts are anof Streamlined Nose Length on Slipstream of High-speed Train alyzed to further elaborate and verify the Authenticity and Passing through a Tunnel. Journal of Applied Fluid Mechanics, feasibility of the proposed causes. This research would 2022, 15(6): 1933-1945. offer valuable insights for train designers and researchers [9] M Baker C, Cheli F, Orellano A, et al. Cross-wind Effects on focusing on drag reduction and energy efficiency optimi-
Road and Rail Vehicles. Vehicle system dynamics, 2009, 47(8): zation. The data comparison serves as a valuable reference 983-1022. for future comparative studies and research on unified [10] Jasim S A, Iswanto A H, Jalil A T, et al. Noise Pollution in integration of the drag optimization with data and experi- Rail Transport. Case Study: Baghdad Subway. Noise Mapping, ments. 2022, 9(1): 113-119. For future research, experimental and computational parameters is suggested to be reported more standardly.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 by the authors.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
